Committee on dispute over submission of ISMD09 Proceedings - Kettler

Committee members: Declan Keane, Jerome Lauret, Saskia Mioduszewski

Report from the committee

A STAR Notes was created holding the fianl report. See PSN0521 : Report from the council commitee on the "ISMD proceedings" for details.

List of email correspondence:

Jetcorr list, October 2009:

Original posting of proceedings: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler (D. Kettler) 27 Oct 2009

Responses and follow-ups (Thread 411):

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Oct 27, 14:40

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Oct 27, 18:58

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Oct 31, 22:14

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Lanny Ray, Oct 27, 19:18

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Oct 28, 16:58

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Oct 28, 21:52

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Joern Putschke, Oct 29, 16:22

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Nov 02, 17:04

3. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Bedanga Mohanty, Oct 28, 20:26

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Oct 29, 20:08

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Bedanga Mohanty, Oct 29, 20:34

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Oct 30, 20:00

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Bedanga Mohanty, Oct 30, 22:40
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Bedanga Mohanty, Oct 31, 22:46
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by James Dunlop, Nov 02, 21:04

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Anthony R. Timmins, Nov 02, 15:36

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Nov 02, 20:52
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Nov 02, 22:42
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Anthony R. Timmins, Nov 03, 10:14

Thread 413: Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler (Tom Trainor) Nov 01, 13:44

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 02, 15:04

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 02, 15:38

1. systematic errors for 2D fits by Tom Trainor, Nov 02, 20:32

1. Re: systematic errors for 2D fits by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 03, 10:42
(_ Re: systematic errors for 2D fits by Tom Trainor, Nov 03, 14:16

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 03, 10:18

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 03, 14:02

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 04, 09:58

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 04, 12:42
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 04, 13:44
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 04, 14:00

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Evan Finch, Nov 04, 10:04

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 04, 11:38

3. systematic errors for 1D fits by Tom Trainor, Nov 03, 13:08

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 05, 15:24

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 05, 18:00
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 06, 10:44
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 06, 11:58
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 06, 16:10

Thread 414:Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler (Tom Trainor) 01 Nov 2009

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 01, 17:26

Thread 418: Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler (Bedanga Mohanty) 03 Nov 2009

Thread 420: Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler (Bedanga Mohanty) 05 Nov 2009

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 04, 21:44

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Nov 04, 22:06
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 06, 16:58
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Dave Kettler, Nov 13, 21:04
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 16, 09:38
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Lanny Ray, Nov 17, 15:36
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 17, 16:20

2. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Lanny Ray, Nov 05, 12:18

1. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 05, 13:28
(_ Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Lanny Ray, Nov 06, 10:12

3. Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler by Tom Trainor, Nov 05, 13:46

Davids ISMD Proceedings (Joern Putschke)

1. Re: Davids ISMD Proceedings by Dave Kettler, Nov 17, 18:44
(_ Re: Davids ISMD Proceedings by Joern Putschke, Nov 18, 08:56
(_ Re: Davids ISMD Proceedings by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 18, 12:06
(_ Re: Davids ISMD Proceedings by Tom Trainor, Nov 18, 15:18
(_ Re: Davids ISMD Proceedings by Dave Kettler, Nov 18, 15:32

Recommendation to publish David Kettler's ISMD09 proceedings (Lanny Ray) 23 Nov 2009

1. Re: Recommendation to publish David Kettler's ISMD09 proceedings by Fuqiang Wang, Nov 23, 19:40
2. Re: Recommendation to publish David Kettler's ISMD09 proceedings by Nu Xu, Nov 24, 11:28

[Fwd: Re: David Kettler's ISMD09 proceedings] (Lanny Ray) 14 Dec 2009

status of David Kettler's ISMD proceedings (Tom Trainor) 31 Jan 2010

Bulkcorr list, December 2009:

Posting of proceedings: ISMD2009 proceedings - David Kettler (Dave Kettler) 04 Dec 2009

STAR-papers list:

October 2009:

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler D. Kettler

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Art Poskanzer
[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Joern Putschke

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Lanny Ray

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Sudhir Raniwala

December 2009:

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Lanny Ray

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Sudhir Raniwala

[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Lanny Ray
[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Tom Trainor
[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Lanny Ray
- [Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Tom Trainor

[Starpapers-l] [Fwd: Re: ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler] Sudhir Raniwala
[Starpapers-l] ISMD 2009 Proceedings - Kettler Tom Trainor

Private Emails Forwarded to the Committee: