Run 13 W Analysis : Final Results : Paper : W Meeting Discussions/ Presentations
Updated on Thu, 2018-05-17 18:10. Originally created by devika on 2017-06-28 12:19.
W meeting - 05/17/18:
Slides
W meeting - 01/10/18:
Slides:
W meeting - 11/08/17:
Jinlong: plots updates : Slides
SPIN PWG presentation (11/ 6/ 17) : requesting convener preview : Slides
Comments / Questions
Carl :
1) EMC systematics theory method - Why W- values are factor two smaller than W+? . I would expect it to be otherwise.
2) What about AL (Z) I hope it will be included.
3) Suggestion to include only data points of run 12 and run 13 in figure 4 and remove everything else. And add another column in the proposed table to put combined AL values through run 11 to run 13.
Oleg:
1) What are the systematic for W ALL?
2) Did any study done to stay away from BEMC margins?
Scott:
1) Suggestions to make 2 legends for W+ and W- for figure 5. Follow up by carl several other suggestions to use different colors for W+ and W- and also for text to make it clear and easily separate W+ and W-
W meeting - 11/05/17:
Devika / Amani : Updates Slides
W meeting - 10/25/17:
Jinlong : Theory_curves Updates : Slides
Devika : Theory_curves Updates: Slides
Discussion :
* Need to decide on Final cuts sets (Weather to use New cuts or Preliminary cuts)
* Finalize theory curves
W meeting - 10/18/17:
Jinlong : Theory_curves Updates : Slides
Discussion : PYTHIA tune version
W meeting - 09/20/17:
Devika : Cut Optimization : Slides
Tau MC issue : link
Offline Discussion : 09/15/17
Jinlong : W AL Theory curves - Slides
Discussion / Comments:
*We need to Include BS model curve which is based on statistical method
*What Unpolarized is used for NNPDFpol1.1 , NNPDF2.3 ? (Need to make this clear)
*MSTW08 for DSSV14 and MSRT for DSSV08, Not big difference for different unpol PDFs
*Make it clear why use a particular unpolarized set (Based on their global analysis)
W meeting - 06/28/17:
Jinlong : Horizontal Error Bars - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/status_discussion_20170628.pdf
Devika : Embedding QA - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/blog/devika/run-13-w-analysis-final-results-embedding-qa
Discussion / Conclusions:
* Remove Horizontal Error bars for run 13 leave them for run 12.
* Shift Run 12 points by a small amount (0.5 units)- Little overlap in the points is OK.
* Embedding - Perhaps try with a larger sample (more study ?)
* BEMC calibration systematics : ?
* Include RHICBOS
Paper Proposal to PWG - 06/26/17:
Comments / Questions from PWG:
W meeting - 06/21/17:
Paper proposal presentation discussion / draft
Matt : TMVA cuts on cross section - https://www.dropbox.com/s/fqszprfv193nmxj/Posik-06182017.pdf?dl=0
W meeting - 06/16/17:
Bernd : Figures - link
W meeting - 06/07/17:
Bernd : Paper / Task Lists: Click Here (link)
W meeting - 05/31/17:
Amani: TMGA cuts : link
Jinlong : Analysis note draft : https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/analysisnote_6.pdf
Collaboration Meeting - 05/16/17
https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/CollaborationMeeting_run13WAL_0.pdf
W meeting - 05/10/17:
Jinlong: Run 13 Paper:- To do list, Time lines - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/WALPubliation.pdf
Draft for Collaboration Meeting - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/CollaborationMeeting.pdf
Discussion / Comments
*Choice of the Journal
*Merging of two years results
Run 13 W AL Paper Proposal Page
https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/pwg/spinanalysisstatushtml/w-2013-analysis-meeting/run-2013-w-al-paper-proposal-webpageW meeting - 05/17/18:
Slides
W meeting - 01/10/18:
Slides:
W meeting - 11/08/17:
Jinlong: plots updates : Slides
SPIN PWG presentation (11/ 6/ 17) : requesting convener preview : Slides
Comments / Questions
Carl :
1) EMC systematics theory method - Why W- values are factor two smaller than W+? . I would expect it to be otherwise.
2) What about AL (Z) I hope it will be included.
3) Suggestion to include only data points of run 12 and run 13 in figure 4 and remove everything else. And add another column in the proposed table to put combined AL values through run 11 to run 13.
Oleg:
1) What are the systematic for W ALL?
2) Did any study done to stay away from BEMC margins?
Scott:
1) Suggestions to make 2 legends for W+ and W- for figure 5. Follow up by carl several other suggestions to use different colors for W+ and W- and also for text to make it clear and easily separate W+ and W-
W meeting - 11/05/17:
Devika / Amani : Updates Slides
W meeting - 10/25/17:
Jinlong : Theory_curves Updates : Slides
Devika : Theory_curves Updates: Slides
Discussion :
* Need to decide on Final cuts sets (Weather to use New cuts or Preliminary cuts)
* Finalize theory curves
W meeting - 10/18/17:
Jinlong : Theory_curves Updates : Slides
Discussion : PYTHIA tune version
W meeting - 09/20/17:
Devika : Cut Optimization : Slides
Tau MC issue : link
Offline Discussion : 09/15/17
Jinlong : W AL Theory curves - Slides
Discussion / Comments:
*We need to Include BS model curve which is based on statistical method
*What Unpolarized is used for NNPDFpol1.1 , NNPDF2.3 ? (Need to make this clear)
*MSTW08 for DSSV14 and MSRT for DSSV08, Not big difference for different unpol PDFs
*Make it clear why use a particular unpolarized set (Based on their global analysis)
W meeting - 06/28/17:
Jinlong : Horizontal Error Bars - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/status_discussion_20170628.pdf
Devika : Embedding QA - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/blog/devika/run-13-w-analysis-final-results-embedding-qa
Discussion / Conclusions:
* Remove Horizontal Error bars for run 13 leave them for run 12.
* Shift Run 12 points by a small amount (0.5 units)- Little overlap in the points is OK.
* Embedding - Perhaps try with a larger sample (more study ?)
* BEMC calibration systematics : ?
* Include RHICBOS
Paper Proposal to PWG - 06/26/17:
Comments / Questions from PWG:
Scott :
1) What is the conclusion of ALL?
**If a plot is not showing a sentence about ALL in the summary/conclusion would be good.
Oleg :
1) What is the Eta overlap for BEMC and EEMC? (Physics Eta vs Lab Eta)
Clarify this in the text to avoid confusions.
2) Horizontal Error bars on the results plots? How to interpret?
Renee:
Will ask later.
Elke:
1) What about Z boson AL ? Is it going to include ?
2) Is the Impact of data on PDFs going to include? (We don’t need NNPDF necessary, we can also do ourselves. GEM collaboration PDFS ??)
Scott and ALL,
**Another presentation to PWG before go to the PWGC would be good. Once pending items are completed!
W meeting - 06/21/17:
Paper proposal presentation discussion / draft
Matt : TMVA cuts on cross section - https://www.dropbox.com/s/fqszprfv193nmxj/Posik-06182017.pdf?dl=0
W meeting - 06/16/17:
Bernd : Figures - link
W meeting - 06/07/17:
Bernd : Paper / Task Lists: Click Here (link)
W meeting - 05/31/17:
Amani: TMGA cuts : link
Jinlong : Analysis note draft : https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/analysisnote_6.pdf
Collaboration Meeting - 05/16/17
https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/CollaborationMeeting_run13WAL_0.pdf
W meeting - 05/10/17:
Jinlong: Run 13 Paper:- To do list, Time lines - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/WALPubliation.pdf
Draft for Collaboration Meeting - https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/STAR/system/files/CollaborationMeeting.pdf
Discussion / Comments
*Choice of the Journal
*Merging of two years results
»
- devika's blog
- Login or register to post comments